Do the ends justify the means?
We are living in a time when our country’s traditional means of governing are being abandoned. The rules, laws, norms and precedents that have guided our nation are being replaced by means that are openly aggressive and hostile toward civilians.
Government aggression toward civilians is not new, but it has generally lived in the shadows because it is at odds with our core principles, goals and identity.
What feels new is the level of openness, tolerance, and even celebration, of government actions that break our traditions and identity as a nation.
- On immigration, the government is breaking the law—arresting, detaining and deporting people living here legally and denying due process, without regard to the Constitution.
- On freedom of speech, the government is intimidating, brutalizing and killing civilians in the streets of America who protest their actions.
- On freedom of the press, the government is silencing journalists and approving media consolidations based on political favors, without regard to the Constitution.
- On religion, the government is trying to establish Christianity as the national religion, without regard to the Constitution.
- On voting, the government is restricting voter access, undermining public trust, bullying election officials, and trying to federalize elections, without regard to the Constitution.
- On governing, the government is attacking public officials who oppose their actions, firing non-partisan public servants, and making international decisions based on self-dealing, without regard to the Constitution.
- On the economy, the government is wreaking national, international and consumer havoc through rollercoaster tariffs, manipulating markets through military actions to enrich the rich, and making pay-to-play official decisions, without regard to the Constitution.
- On culture, the government is rewriting history, attacking science, destroying the planet, weakening education, stripping women’s rights and autonomy, attacking immigrants, people of color and the LGBTQIA2S+ community, and punishing businesses that support equality, without regard to the Constitution.
Supporters hold their noses and tolerate these actions, saying that the ends justify the means. They believe that ethical ends justify questionable means.
But what exactly are the ends? Toward what goal are they striving? Are these ends ethical?
The stated goal for the GOP is to retain, and gain, power and control for the good of the nation. But what good can come for the nation when the very means of our system are destroyed?
Perhaps the underlying goal of destruction is not for the good of the nation, but for the good of the people driving and benefitting from the destruction.
Based on their actions, it is clear is that the destroyers of means don’t subscribe to the bedrock belief of our country, that all are created equal.
Our founders rejected tyranny and established a government on the belief that all men are created equal.
Though they did not achieve it, they gave us the goals and means to create a more perfect union by establishing rules, laws and norms that disperse power. Fundamentally, they understood that concentrated power creates tyrants.
The tenets of our democracy—rule of law, individual rights, freedom of the press, separation of powers, co-equal branches, free and fair elections, multi-jurisdictional governments of, by and for “the people” are the means to diffuse political powers.
The tenets of our economy—competition, entrepreneurship, public and private investments, free markets, sensible regulations and reasonable taxes on everyone are the means to diffuse economic power and ensure a fair and level playing field.
The tenets of our culture—understanding history, protecting the natural world, improving lives through science, celebrating differences, welcoming immigrants, and supporting arts are the means to diffuse cultural power and ensure that everyone has the opportunity to pursue happiness.
Today’s would-be tyrants must destroy all of the means that keep power dispersed to achieve their ends—a nation of inequality, where people who are wealthy, white, Christian, straight and male rule.
Not only are the means to their end unethical—the ends themselves are unethical, immoral and contrary to our most core value as a nation.
What are we to do?
First, we must move past our exasperation and despair, and focus everything on dispersing power in government, the economy and our culture.
Tyranny can only take hold if power is consolidated, which is why the dismantling of means is occurring on every front. We must resist the consolidation of power and push freedom at every level. (This sounds like the old Grand Old Party!)
Politically, we must replace elected officials who support, or do not actively fight, coercion, corruption and inequality. We must abandon propaganda media, support independent journalism, strengthen state and local government, prosecute murderers, give money to the ACLU and other organizations challenging illegal government actions, especially those that detain people without due process. We must disperse political power.
Economically, we must stop feeding billionaires and the systems that create them! Stop buying or using their products when you can, tell them your reasons, post to social media, tell others. Support ethical businesses, small businesses, entrepreneurs and unions, demand lower costs for consumers and give to local food shelves. Tax the rich. We must disperse economic power.
Culturally, we must value science and history, protect our planet, celebrate differences, support immigrants and artists, go to multicultural festivals, watch women’s sports, give to non-profits, and, most importantly, be our full, beautiful selves, pursuing as much happiness as possible. We must disperse cultural power.
Our founders gave us the the bedrock value of equality:
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” Declaration of Independence, 1776
They gave us the ends and the means to support this value, the Constitution.
“We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.” United States Constitution, 1789
We must preserve these ends and means for our posterity, as they did for us.
Do the ends justify the means? No, even when the ends are noble. When the ends are immoral, the means cannot be otherwise.
By their fruits, you will know them.